Ubuntu News
When failure becomes fatal: The consequences of defective referral forms in CCMA and bargaining council disputes
The rules governing the conduct of proceedings before the Commission for Conciliation, Mediation and Arbitration (CCMA) and the various bargaining councils are binding on litigants before that forum. Any failure to obey the rules will attract the necessary consequences. In the Labour Appeal Court’s (LAC) judgment in Adams v National Bargaining Council for the Freight…
Read MoreRestraints of trade in light of recent judgments
There is a common assumption among employees (and many employers) that restraint of trade covenants are invalid and unenforceable especially in light of the right for South Africa citizens to choose their trade, occupation, or profession freely as enshrined in the Constitution of the Republic of South Africa, 1996 (“the Constitution”). This assumption is incorrect…
Read MoreIs it legal for managers to work Sundays and public holidays without overtime pay?
Yes, but only if the manager can be regarded as a “senior managerial employee”, or if the manager earns over the relevant threshold determined by the Minister of Labour from time to time (currently R211 596 per annum, or R17 633 per month). This may, however, be superseded by a contract of employment that provides…
Read MoreReasonable expectation of permanent employment
Nowalaza and others v The office of the Chief Justice and others and another (J1177/2017) [2017] LC: The applicants in the recent decision in were judges’ secretaries (usually referred to as judges’ clerks or judges’ associates) employed by the Office of the Chief Justice (“OCJ”) and working in the Labour Court and the Labour Appeal…
Read MoreFixed Term Contract
Enforce security Group v Mwelase and 46 0thers-(2017) LAC In this case the employer employed security officers and placed them at the premises of its clients. The security officers’ employment contracts included an automatic termination clause which provided for the termination of the employee’s contract of employment on termination of the contract between the employer…
Read MoreDuty to Bargain
Minister of Defence v SANDU and others 2007 (4) BCLR 398 (SCA) The Supreme Court of Appeal had to decide whether there was a legal enforceable duty on the South African National Defence Force as the employer to bargain collectively with the military trade union and if there was such a duty and the employer…
Read MoreSelf-Isolation and Employees’ Sick Leave:
The rights and responsibilities of employers and employees alike are customarily embodied in the age old “control test” developed from an early stage in South African jurisprudence. Control and supervision of a particular person (the Employee) by another (the Employer), in various respects, has long been a defining characteristic of the common employer-employee relationship. Arguably…
Read MoreDishonesty and misrepresentation
Employment law places a high premium on honesty. The foundation of the employment relationship is trust and confidence. Where this foundation is damaged, the parties cannot be expected to continue with the employment relationship. The case of Mothiba v Exxaro Coal (Pty) Ltd t/a Grootgeluk Coal Mine considers the consequences of dishonesty and misrepresentation by an employee. …
Read MoreEmployers cannot “buy their way out” of retrenchment procedures
In the recent South African Labour Appeal Court (“LAC”) decision of Total South Africa (Pty) Ltd v Meyer and others, the LAC, in addressing the issue of whether the decision to grant maximum compensation for a substantively and procedurally unfair retrenchment was exercised judicially, made significant remarks in respect of an employer’s obligation to comply with…
Read MoreHigh Court dismisses application to set aside B-BBEE Commission’s findings: lessons for stakeholders
A recent South African High Court decision explores some interesting issues regarding the scope of the Broad-Based Black Economic Empowerment Commission’s (the “Commission”) investigative powers, as well as what constitutes a fronting practice. CRRC E Loco Supply (“CRRC”) was incorporated as a joint venture between CSR: Zhuzhou Electrical Locomotives (a Chinese-owned entity) (“CSR”) and Matsete Basadi Consortium…
Read More